First off, I think for GvG only the leader has to be online to attack, or anybody to attack once battle started.
Maybe use some kind of math for a Guild damage, not individual damage, like... add all player lvls together % members = dmg.
GvG you attack Guild Halls, 1 lvl = 1k hp, can only attack once every 2 hrs (with enough players there's alot more likely someone's online to click attack once).
Top guild has like guild hall around lvl 16-17? (estimate) thats 16-17k.
My guild's hall is lvl 12, even though we're alot weaker in the IOU/rank score, that's 12k.
now, even though they might have lvl 300's in there, they've got the divide that total number more times so it would be really close battle, then we could add skill points, like the orb system but with Guild battle victory/loses, 1 victory = 100 exp, 1 loss = 50 exp, so it would take a REALLY long time for any guild to pull ahead, even top ranked ones.
Skills.
Attack Damage. (1 lvl = 1% extra damage per attack)
Defence. (1 lvl = 1% damage knocked off each attack)
Rewards: 10k stone put into the Guild Hall. (not too big of a reward at first but add's up.)
PS. all my guild lvls % 23 = 217 (rounded up/down) so my guild would hit for 217 every 2 hours and would take 6.5 days minimum to kill the top tanked guild at 17k hp.
Maybe use some kind of math for a Guild damage, not individual damage, like... add all player lvls together % members = dmg.
GvG you attack Guild Halls, 1 lvl = 1k hp, can only attack once every 2 hrs (with enough players there's alot more likely someone's online to click attack once).
Top guild has like guild hall around lvl 16-17? (estimate) thats 16-17k.
My guild's hall is lvl 12, even though we're alot weaker in the IOU/rank score, that's 12k.
now, even though they might have lvl 300's in there, they've got the divide that total number more times so it would be really close battle, then we could add skill points, like the orb system but with Guild battle victory/loses, 1 victory = 100 exp, 1 loss = 50 exp, so it would take a REALLY long time for any guild to pull ahead, even top ranked ones.
Skills.
Attack Damage. (1 lvl = 1% extra damage per attack)
Defence. (1 lvl = 1% damage knocked off each attack)
Rewards: 10k stone put into the Guild Hall. (not too big of a reward at first but add's up.)
PS. all my guild lvls % 23 = 217 (rounded up/down) so my guild would hit for 217 every 2 hours and would take 6.5 days minimum to kill the top tanked guild at 17k hp.